“You don't tug on Superman's cape.
You don't spit into the wind.
You don't pull the mask of the ol' Lone Ranger
and you don't mess around with Jim (/Slim)!”
-- Jim Croce
I hope starting with that quote will not make the message
surrounding this sports story glib, because it really is the first of
two special stories I will be doing for this blog on similar
subjects.
It is time that the world accepts the GLBT population, by reason
or by force.
(And “reason” is quickly leaving the playing field.)
To show how far we have to go, two “Special Report” stories this week on the blog.
For the first one: Let's take an extended look at an incident on
ESPN's
Grantland site which has raised more than a few
negative eyebrows.
It all started rather innocuously: An
January
15, 2014 article written by Caleb Hannan on a “Dr. V” who had
created a putter which appeared to significantly enhance one's
putting game.
The creator, a Dr. Essay Anne Vanderbilt, had put up a YouTube
video (in the linked article) with no less than former CBS golf
commentator Gary McCord singing the praises of a new putter he had
discovered from Dr. Vanderbilt.
(And, believe you and me, with as long as McCord has been around
the sport of golf, his endorsement has to carry some degree of
weight.)
Dr. Vanderbilt was a physicist, who had been researching golf
patents going back to the 1950's, and appeared to make a putter that
could be saleable in a sport which even most smaller companies now
believe may be about to die in the United States, with a rapidly
aging demographic.
So, the person from Grantland wanted to interview her. The
response, at best, indicated that much of what was going on was
secretive, at best.
From the article:
“
I have no issues as long as the following protocols are
followed because of my association with classified documents,” she
wrote. “Allow me to elucidate; I have the benefits under the
freedom of information act the same privileges as federal judges, my
anonymity is my security as well as my livelihood, since I do
numerous active projects … If the aforementioned is agreeable to
you, please respond to this communique at your convenience so we can
schedule our lively nuncupative off the record collogue.”
I can tell you that I associate with certain people who have
connections with various well-known parties, who have asked me to
keep any information (given to them in confidence) I get from them,
similarly, secret. So, though I find this uncommon, I do not find
anything outside the verbage used to be particularly unusual.
So he tried to go through McCord to try to smooth the waters a
bit. Hannan found out, from McCord, that Vanderbilt was not joking
about classified documents – we're talking Department of Defense
here.
The first mistake Caleb Hannan made was trying to make was going
beyond the science to the scientist.
She was a tall woman, a bit of red hair, and a Vanderbilt. A lot
to study there.
McCord cautioned the
Grantland author not to do so, and
basically warned him to “hang on” when he finally was going to be
able to contact Dr. Vanderbilt.
And McCord didn't leave his endorsement of Dr. Vanderbilt's putter
to YouTube. A PGA professional had picked up the club and was using
it in the 2012 Wells Fargo Championship, and McCord was singing it's
praises in the tournament. A clip of that is also on the original
Grantland article, linked above. The golfer, Aaron Baddeley,
would quickly transition to another putter, even though his
performance significantly improved with Dr. Vanderbilt's club. No
true reason was given.
So that led Hannan to finally weave through the web of Dr.
Vanderbilt and actually get to talk to the mysterious doctor.
Accent, deep voice, migraines if she ever spent more than a couple
hours outdoors – the last precluding any personal use of her
handiwork.
She also revealed a dark side to her invention. In a six-month
period, her golf company's office had been broken in to NINE TIMES,
presumably to attempt to either steal the plans of or completely
discredit the club which she had created.
The next step was actually to get the club and have Hannan see it
for himself. It worked wonders immediately, and he found out that
McCord had been information by Dr. Vanderbilt that she had worked on
government projects like the Stealth Bomber.
But an e-mail to Dr. Vanderbilt which sang the praises of the
putter was met... coldly.
“
As I clearly stated at the onset of your unsolicited
probing, your focus must be on the benefits of the Science for the
Golfer not the scientist, however, at this juncture you are in
reversal of your word, as well as neophytic in your modus operandi of
understanding the science of Yar. If you were observant or should I
state; had the mental aptitude of ratiocination you would have
gleaned or inquired about the advantages of the Inertia Matrix … If
you are what you presented yourself to [Gary McCord], as a golf nut,
then you should be in shock and awe that someone has given the
golfing milieu a scientific breakthrough as revolutionary as the
two-piece rubber core golf ball was a hundred years ago!!!”
This created the second mistake Caleb made: Hannan's experience
with the putter had piqued his interest so much that he decided to
dig into Dr. Vanderbilt's story. Finding no record of any such
person as a Dr. Essay Anne Vanderbilt until about 10 years ago or so,
he dug further.
It was a lawsuit that was filed by Dr. Vanderbilt for sexual
discrimination in Arizona that finally unraveled the mess.
She lost the lawsuit when the judge ordered her to sign an
affidavit so that the city could (like Hannan) explore Dr.
Vanderbilt's background – that she'd always been Dr. Essay Anne
Vanderbilt.
I think you can tell where this is going, especially from my
initial statement: She had not. The person from the city sued who
was contacted all but tipped off the whole mess by using “she”
and “her” as if the quotation marks I just threw around those two
pronouns were verbalized.
And then, Caleb Hannan showed his hand, and outed Dr. Essay Anne
Vanderbilt as a transsexual who had never attended the colleges or
anything else which she had indicated.
But the deception on the colleges was not the point: Hannan
crossed the line, cleanly, when he outed Dr. Vanderbilt as a
transsexual in a country where only being as different as “THEY
DON'T CARE ABOUT ALABAMA!” after the Iron Bowl is a death penalty
offense – or being considered a bandwagoning 49ers fan would've
been one had the bullets found their intended target.
There are still many locations in this country that are so
backwards that they would have no problem executing anybody different
than them in such manners if they could get away with it. As a
result (and I speak from nine years on the streets of San Francisco
with common knowledge of the Castro District), many members of the
GLBT community – especially the T – live in constant fear of
their lives, and, in many cases, not the least from their families.
Once Gary McCord got word Hannan had found out and exposed Dr.
Vanderbilt's identity, he (and almost certainly quite angrily)
stopped speaking to him.
The ensuing communications from Dr. Vanderbilt became much
angrier, much less stable, and much more indicative of a person who
was being bullied (and she felt, as well, by Hannan, as well as
others) for being who she was.
On October 18, 2013, Dr. Essay Anne Vanderbilt killed herself, and
it appeared to the pleasure of at least one in-law in the family, who
contacted Hannan with the news.
-
To say the shit hit the fan on the
Grantland article would
be kind.
Within 48 hours,
Grantland's lines were lit up by people
outraged that the article made print.
On Monday, Bill Simmons, the editor of Grantland,
attempted
to take to his own defense.
It took Simmons only a few hours of the outrage he read to realize
that Grantland screwed up.
Speaking with my knowledge of the GLBT community, I almost have to
say it should be fatal to the
Grantland column.
Why?
Let's start with a very interesting web series that TSN (the
Canadian ESPN) ran on “Reorientation: The Culture of Casual
Homophobia”.
It has three parts. The videos are linked here:
Part
1.
Part
2.
Part
3.
Homosexuality (and being a transgender even more so) is a death
knell in sports which makes one considered lesser and not worthy of
participation, if not basically being injured/killed outright.
Anyone who has not read of the numerous people murdered for being
LGBT in this country – and the innumberable additional human beings
who kill themselves at the literal direction of bullies for being
LGBT – either is ignorant by choice or by a very large stroke of
blind luck.
The final mistake Hannan made was that the author had outed Dr.
Vanderbilt to one of her investors – before she killed herself when
that investor pulled any further involvement as a result.
Frankly, that should expose the author (and
Grantland/ESPN)
to money damages for the wrongful death, and probable criminal
charges for Hannan. The suicide now becomes a wrongful death
situation, and, the “numerous lawyers” for
Grantland and
ESPN aside, there will be a lawsuit. This was actually going to be
discussed on Deadspin for a period of time, until it was decided that
a lawsuit was ultimately the best way to proceed.
And Simmons makes some very valid points in his attempt to
apologize:
- The high suicide rate of transgenders. It should come as no
surprise that most of them are encouraged by forces around them to
conform or die – often choosing the latter out of frustration,
pain, bullying, and the inherent internal conflict transgenders
have. According to LiveScience,
no fewer than two out of five of all transgenders are believed to
have attempted suicide.
- That it was never clear in the article whether Hannan was
going to out Dr. Vanderbilt.
- And that it was never discussed before her death as to what
was going to happen in that regard at Grantland or ESPN.
- That the second cardinal sin against a transgender was also
violated – not getting the pronouns correct. GLAAD publishes a
style guide on how to properly deal with that.
- That Hannan had a “chill down his spine” also could be
read the wrong way.
- And the fact he pulled the trigger on the ultimate cardinal
sin, outing Dr. Vanderbilt, destroying her livelihood as a result,
and directly driving her to her suicide.
As a result of these errors, Dr. Essay Anne Vanderbilt is dead.
And ESPN and
Grantland should be held liable for that death.
This would be no different than if ESPN had outed an athlete,
previously in the closet, on the current US Olympic Team, and
something happened to him or her in Sochi, Russia. (Why that might
very well be a problem will be addressed in my second “Special
Report” on the farcical Five-Ring Circus in Russia (and the bad
need for a GLBT Jesse Owens Moment) this week.)
This is no different than an athlete being outed in a college or
high school, and eventually bullied, at minimum, out of sports, or
the school, or the community he or she lives in, or his or her life
outright.
Again, as often happens with inexcusable penalties like the
zero-tolerance penalties against clear tributes to dead friends in
the end zone, etc. and so forth, ESPN (especially, since it seems to
glorify homophobia in various forms and fashions – whether it
chooses to or not (and it certainly does not do so universally))
needs to understand the culture of sports in this country: Where
“Power Over”, even (and often) to the point of rape and worse, is
the ultimate goal.
Even a straight woman can no longer, in my honest opinion, expect
appropriate conduct from a man, especially in a culture which
glorifies absolute power on the part of said man over everyone in his
path (we've even had a Congresscritter call for the concept of
“legitimate rape”). It, at best, has to be enforced through the
law – criminal AND civil. (And, usually only when the woman is
considered economically important. I speak from experience in this
regard.)
Moreover, it's 100 times worse when you start talking anybody in
the GLBT community.
This is why Chile's motto -- “By reason or by force.” –
applies. Either this world needs to recognize the right of GLBT
human beings to pursue whatever form of athletic or other endeavor
without fear of bullying or worse, or the Anakin Skywalker Effect
needs to take hold, and that right needs to be forced on the rest of
the world.
I fear we are very close to that latter situation. “Reason”,
in this subject, has finished off Dr. Essay Anne Vanderbilt in a
manner in which much of our American culture finds the desired
result.
“Reason” has allowed an International Olympic Committee, for
the second time in twelve years, to award a Winter Olympics to an
openly homophobic city. (More on that after the Super Bowl.)
-
I have received a number of sources (from a number of parties) on
this subject, in addition to the two initial
Grantland pieces.
The women's issues sister blog to
Deadspin,
Jezebel,
ran
a story on January 18
th, three days after the initial
Grantland article.
Deadspin, itself,
ran
a catalogue of many of the issues surrounding the article on the
19
th.
Another sister Kinja site,
Uppercutting, went so far as to
call Hannan a
coward.
Much of the rhetoric of some disgust and a lot of discussion of
the Grantland pieces overlaps between the three articles, and many
others on the subject.
However, most stunning is that
Grantland had somebody who
could well have easily stopped all this.
Christina Kahrl is a baseball writer for ESPN. She could easily
have seen this article, and seen all the problems she
delineated
in a scathing piece against Hannan and
Grantland.
Why do I say this? She serves on the board of directors for
GLAAD. On top of that, she has been known to be transgender herself
since her days on
Baseball Prospectus.
Essay Anne Vanderbilt died because she, in this
homophobic/transphobic world of sports, did not appear to have the
human right of decency of self-identification.
For this, ESPN, Bill Simmons, Hannan, and
Grantland should
pay through the fucking nose – and tack on jobs and the entire
Grantland project while you're at it.
It truly appears that ESPN, as a “corporate citizen”, is
guilty of a felony here – a hate crime, no less. And Caleb Hannan
should honestly be charged with something, if the laws on the books
exist in the relevant state.
We live in a sports world, today, where being only as different as
not a big enough fan, a fan for not long enough, or even just not
willing to throw oneself off the cliff for the team's latest loss is
grounds for murder.
We live in a sports world, today, where being only as different as
not as elite of an athlete as others is grounds for assault, battery,
and dehumanization.
We live in a sports world, today, where taking time out for one's
own life out of sports is no longer allowed – not only in the
24-hour news cycles of ESPNFS1NBCSNCBSSN...
We live in a real world where being different is grounds for
death, whatever the manifestation of “difference” is. And when,
in the interest of “getting the story”, an overzealous report
exposes those differences to the point where it basically opens the
gates of Hell, they should expect to be burned.
I add two further perspectives (which are good enough to stand on
their own merit – adding my own thoughts, except on rare points, is
almost pointless) on the subject along the lines of Christina Kahrl:
First, I add this piece from
Maria
Dahvana Headley, to which I only make one further comment: If
the story is the entire thing, then there is only one option: Don't
run the story, in any kind.
And then this article, short and sweet, from Melissa McEwan at
Shakesville.
McEwan called it “careless, cruel, and unaccountable”.
And, until those three things are changed, it's time for heads to
roll at ESPN and
Grantland.